Why an FHA Appraisal Required Repairs Before We Could Close

November 04, 2026•4 min read

Explore FHA loan optionsIn a recent FHA loan I closed, the appraisal brought up several property issues the homeowner had to address. There was peeling paint, drainage concerns involving pipes, and a review of the area beneath the home. A homeowner-built outdoor fire feature without a permit also raised questions.

The borrower had a list of items to work through before closing. We ultimately closed the loan, but the experience is a useful example of why property condition belongs in the financing conversation early.

I am keeping the homeowner's identifying details private. Every property and appraisal is different, so this experience should help you prepare rather than predict what an appraiser will require at your home.

Why property condition matters on an FHA loan

An FHA appraisal includes an opinion of value and a review of readily observable conditions against FHA property requirements. A home can support the requested loan amount and still have a condition that needs attention.

Under HUD's FHA handbook, the review addresses issues affecting the home's safety, security, and soundness. Where a concern cannot be resolved through the appraiser's observations, further inspection or repairs may be required.

That helps explain why something a homeowner has lived with for years can become a loan condition. The lender must evaluate the property under the requirements for the new financing.

What this particular appraisal brought up

The peeling paint and pipe-related drainage concerns were among the items the borrower needed to address. The appraiser also reviewed beneath the home. That part of the process can surprise homeowners who expect the visit to focus mainly on room count, square footage, and comparable sales.

HUD's guidance calls for visual observation of safely accessible crawl-space areas. Evidence of deficiencies can lead to repair conditions or an inspection by a qualified professional. The scope depends on what is visible and whether the area can be accessed safely.

The outdoor fire feature brought another issue into the discussion because it had been built by the homeowner without a permit. The lesson is to disclose additions and improvements early and gather any available permit records. The appropriate resolution depends on the actual condition, local requirements, and the lender's review.

Would a conventional loan avoid those repairs?

Conventional and FHA property reviews can produce different conditions. However, switching loan types does not automatically clear a property concern.

Fannie Mae's conventional appraisal guidance also addresses deficiencies affecting safety, soundness, or structural integrity. Minor maintenance may be treated differently from a more serious problem. The specific findings matter.

I compare financing options based on qualification, costs, and the property itself. A different loan program is something to evaluate carefully, especially if changing programs would mean additional expense or a longer timeline.

How to prepare before the appraiser arrives

Start by telling your loan originator about known leaks, drainage problems, peeling paint, unfinished work, and improvements that may lack permits. Have any existing inspection reports or repair records available. That gives everyone a better opportunity to identify questions early.

Arrange safe access to the areas the appraiser needs to observe. If work is required, get clarity on the written condition before hiring someone or assuming a particular fix will satisfy it.

I also recommend discussing how completion will be documented and whether a return visit or specialist report is needed. Repair costs, follow-up fees, and scheduling can affect both the budget and the closing date. Keep receipts and relevant records, and confirm the lender's documentation requirements.

An appraisal has a different scope from a home inspection

HUD encourages buyers to arrange their own home inspection. An appraisal does not provide the same detailed examination of the home's condition, systems, and potential repair needs. FHA does not perform that inspection for the buyer.

The takeaway from this closing is to leave room for the property review in your financing plan. An appraisal condition can create extra work, but a clear understanding of the requirements helps everyone decide the next step.

If you are considering FHA financing or have questions about a property's condition, contact Adaptive Mortgage Solutions. I can review the financing options with you and explain how appraisal requirements may affect your loan.


By Michael Kanter, NMLS #1081117 | Adaptive Mortgage Solutions, Inc., NMLS #2022974.

Michael Kanter

Michael Kanter

Michael Kanter is the owner of Adaptive Mortgage Solutions, Inc., based in Irvine, California. He helps homeowners, self-employed borrowers, and real estate investors compare mortgage options, including DSCR and cash-out refinancing. Individual NMLS #1081117; company NMLS #2022974.

Back to Blog