
Should You Use a Home Equity Loan to Pay Off Credit Cards?
By Michael Kanter, NMLS #1081117 | Adaptive Mortgage Solutions, Inc., NMLS #2022974
When someone calls me about paying off credit cards, I start with two numbers: what they owe and what actually leaves their checking account each month. Then I ask a third question: if those card payments disappeared, what would they want that money to do?
A home equity loan can give a homeowner with several balances a single payoff schedule. It can also turn a short-term credit card problem into a debt that follows them for years. Here’s how I compare the choices.
Put the payments on the same footing
Write down each card’s balance, interest rate, minimum payment, and the payment you actually make. If your minimums add up to $600 but you’ve been paying $1,000, those are two different comparisons. One tells us how much breathing room you need. The other tells us how quickly you could get out of debt without a new loan.
With a fixed-rate home equity loan, you borrow a lump sum and make scheduled principal and interest payments. If your existing first mortgage stays in place, leave its payment on both sides of the comparison. Include any financed closing costs in the new balance: paying off $40,000 in cards with a loan that also finances $3,000 in fees means repaying $43,000.
Decide what the lower payment buys you
Say you currently pay $1,000 a month toward your cards and a proposed loan would require $600. That’s $400 of monthly breathing room. It isn’t automatically $400 of interest saved. Ask when the cards would be paid off at your current pace, when the new loan would end, and how much you would pay under each plan. If the new loan runs longer, ask for a second comparison assuming you keep paying $1,000.
Sometimes the smaller required payment is the point: a household needs room for groceries or a repair without reaching for the cards again. But if the same expenses will go back on those cards every month, consolidation can leave you with both the home equity payment and fresh card balances.
Consider what you’re putting on the line
Credit card debt is generally unsecured. A home equity loan is secured by your home, which means missed payments can put the home at risk of foreclosure. Before taking that step, compare staying with your current payoff plan, asking your card issuer about hardship options, or using an unsecured installment loan. The right choice may be the one that lets you leave your house out of it.
For a first look, use the debt consolidation payment calculator. Enter only the debts you intend to pay off. Then ask me for the comparison the calculator can’t make for you: given your timeline, your first mortgage, and the costs on an actual offer, would I recommend doing the loan at all?
Compare HELOC and home equity loan options

